top of page

Who Can You Trust?

Writer: Dr. Lloyd
Dr. Lloyd
5 minutes ago
3 min read

Not psychopaths.


An essay by Lloyd I Sederer MD


The indifference of psychopaths to others is striking. We are astounded by their behaviors that reveal a belief that rules are made for others, not them.

 

While psychopaths may be entertaining on TV and movies, their close presence in our lives should have us checking to see if we still have our wallet. Their inflated sense of self may take them to high places but their stay there is tenuous and transitory. Those whom they lure into their grasp soon lose patience and forgiveness. We can allow for honest mistakes but not those by those who take us for fools.


The infamous case of Bernie Madoff had Jon Stewart joke that when the Judge gave the convicted man a choice of 150 years in jail or walking free but unaccompanied out of the courthouse, Madoff chose the former.

.....................................

Jon Ronson, a journalist and a TED speaker, was intrigued by psychopaths. When he came upon the Diagnostic Manual of Psychiatric Disorders, the DSM, he 'diagnosed' himself with a dozen disorders – revealing perhaps both his own troubles as well as those of the DSM, the “bible” of psychiatric diagnosis.


His discovery of the DSM led him to the mother church, so to speak, of the critics of psychiatry, namely the Scientologists. One Scientologist remarked, so said Ronson, if he wanted to see how far-fetched psychiatric diagnosis can go then he had a case for him. He did.


Ronson then tells the tale of venturing from his hometown of London to a place he had never experienced: Broadmoor Hospital, a long-term mental asylum that was is a remnant of days past. There he meets Tony, a psychopath who thought he could elude punishment for assault by feigning madness. Boy did he make a mistake. Tony had been in Broadmoor for 12 years. Far more than any criminal sentence he might have copped. Not very smart. There is also a diagnosis for that.


Notably, psychopaths in the U.S. rarely use the NGRI (Not Guilty By Reason of Insanity) defense because they usually know it will deliver more time locked up in a mental hospital than would be their prison sentence. 


No matter what Tony tried, he couldn't find a way to be released from Broadmoor.  He reportedly said that whatever he told his doctors seemed to be used against him to continue his involuntary hospitalization. I don’t doubt that. Ironically, in the US getting into a psychiatric hospital is a challenge (high “demand”, low “supply”) and when “successful’ it is usually no more than a week.


Ronson was captivated by Tony and his mental aberration(s), an effect psychopaths are known to achieve. Ronson decided he wanted to penetrate the “ruling class” of psychopaths, namely corporate titans, he opined. He tried to visit inmates imprisoned from Enron Corp. offenses, but they wouldn't bother with him. He did, however, find Al Dunlop (Chainsaw Al, living in Florida), renowned in the 1990s for his ‘neutron bomb’ CEO cost-cutting tactics of decimating company workforces (employees).


Because Ronson had trained in the HARE PCLR (a psychopathy checklist widely used among forensic experts, developed by Robert Hare), as he observed a “titan” he would check box after box in his mind. Everything Chainsaw Al reported was used against him in court.

......................

Ronson's suggests that checklists and diagnostic manuals notwithstanding, neither he -- or anyone else -- should spend time with a psychopath, perhaps aside from getting a story.

Isn't that what the PCLR and the DSM would have said?

.....................................................................................................................

Lloyd Sederer MD is a psychiatrist, public health doctor, and non-fiction writer

==================================================================================


I respond personally to what Lloyd Sederer writes because he makes me feel like he is sitting at this very kitchen table, gently explaining to me, with great knowledge, insight and patience, what is happening to my loved one and what my family and I can do about it.

Glenn Close (from the Foreword)

 

Dr. Sederer's book, The Family Guide to Mental Health Care, is for families with a loved one with a serious mental illness.

 
 
 

Comments


  • Twitter Basic Square
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook Basic Square
bottom of page